When you’re looking for help with tax debt, two names often come up, Optima Tax Relief and Precision Tax Relief. Both companies have years of experience and nationwide reach, but they differ significantly in customer experience, transparency, and how they approach your case.
Here’s how they stack up against each other.
| Feature | Precision Tax Relief | Optima Tax Relief |
| Years in Business | 50+ years (since 1967) | 12+ years (since 2010) |
| Minimum Debt Required | Minimum $10,000 | $10,000 minimum |
| Pricing Model | Free first assessment, flat fee structure & flexible payments | Custom quote per case |
| Money-Back Guarantee | 30 days | 15 days |
| Focus Areas | Federal tax resolution, IRS negotiation, bookkeeping | IRS & state tax resolution |
| Mobile App | ❌ No app | ✅ Yes |
| Accreditations | A+ BBB, American Society of Tax Problem Solvers, NAEA, AICPA | A+ BBB, BCA, National Association of Tax Professionals |
| Average Resolution Time | 2–6 months | 2–6 months |
| Ethics Award | BBB Torch Award for Ethics (winner 2024) Honored with Prestigious BBB Torch Award for Ethics |
BBB Torch Award for Ethics (past years) |
Precision Tax Relief:
Precision Tax Relief stands out for its customer-first approach. Instead of routing you through multiple departments, you’re assigned a dedicated tax professional who knows your case inside and out.
The company is known for its clear, flat-rate pricing, meaning you’ll know exactly what you’re paying upfront, no hidden fees, no upselling later.
- 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee: Twice as long as Optima’s, giving you more confidence.
- Top BBB Rating (4.9/5): Among the highest in the industry.
- Comprehensive IRS Solutions: Offer in Compromise, Penalty Abatement, Innocent Spouse Relief, and back tax filing.
- Bookkeeping & Tax Prep: Precision Tax offers both; Optima Tax provides tax prep only.
Optima Tax Relief:
Optima Tax Relief serves clients who prefer handling parts of the tax relief process through a mobile app. The company’s proprietary Optima™ App allows users to upload documents, track case progress, and communicate with their assigned team directly from their phone. Optima typically assists individuals with larger tax debts (around $10,000 or more) and provides case-by-case pricing after an initial review.
Key Differences That Matter
1. Customer Experience
Precision focuses on human support, a single case manager handles your file from start to finish, avoiding the confusion of team-based systems. Optima offers a more structured corporate model, which may lead to longer communication gaps according to BBB feedback.
2. Pricing and Transparency
Precision gives flat-rate quotes upfront, no surprises later. Optima’s pricing varies case by case, making it harder to estimate total cost until after the initial phase.
3. Guarantee Policy
Precision’s 30-day guarantee doubles Optima’s 15-day offer. That extra time matters if you’re uncertain or need reassurance before committing.
4. Reputation and Recognition
Both firms hold A+ BBB ratings and have won Torch Awards for Ethics, but Precision consistently appears on reputable “Best Tax Relief Companies” lists (CBS News, Investopedia, and others).
| Metric | Precision Tax Relief | Optima Tax Relief |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A+ |
| BBB Complaints (3-year) | 3 (1 closed) | 795 (289 closed) |
| Google Rating | 4.9 / 5 ⭐ | 4.1 / 5 ⭐ |
| Trustpilot Rating | 5.0 / 5 ⭐ | 4.4 / 5 ⭐ |
| BBB Torch Award for Ethics | ✅ Yes (recent winner) | ✅ Yes (past years) |
5. Bookkeeping and Ongoing Tax Support
Precision goes beyond tax resolution and also offers full bookkeeping and tax preparation both online and in-office. This ensures clients stay compliant, organized, and IRS-ready at all times. Optima, on the other hand, focuses solely on tax preparation and does not provide ongoing bookkeeping services.
Which Should You Choose?
Precision Tax Relief is the right choice if you want a professional, transparent process. They also offer a free first assessment. This means a licensed expert reviews your case in detail, outlines real resolution options, and provides a clear flat-fee quote before you pay anything.
Optima Tax Relief provides a free consultation and a mobile app. The Optima Tax App, helps users upload documents and track progress, but their process starts with an upfront investigation fee and costs that vary by case.
Both firms are reputable and accredited, but if you value transparency, personal guidance, and predictable costs, Precision Tax Relief is the better fit.
Your tax relief shouldn’t wait.
Get your free case review now and see why Precision Tax Relief’s flat-fee process and award-winning ethics make all the difference.
Frequently Asked Questions
Precision Tax Relief focuses on federal tax cases.
Optima’s plans are case-based and typically depend on the debt amount and service level.
Neither Precision Tax Relief nor Optima Tax Relief typically takes cases under $10,000 in IRS tax debt.
Yes. Optima offers tax preparation, but Precision goes further by including bookkeeping and compliance support.
Yes, it’s an accredited company.
They help with IRS resolution and tax preparation, while Precision’s licensed professionals also manage ongoing bookkeeping and compliance.